Thursday, March 18, 2010
Young PCO Austrian Had 5 IVF Cycles Over 3 Years And Is Ready To Give Up - Short Protocol, CGH Advised & Keep Trying!
Dear Dr. Ramirez,
Thanks for taking the time to do this, I have read several of your previous answers on the website and I am looking forward to hear your thoughts on our case. I am writing from Austria. Both my husband and I are 30, we have been doing IVF/ICSI for the past 3 years (5 cycles) with no success. My husband has the CF gene and no vas deferens (0 count). Everything is fine with me (blood work, hormones, etc). I had a laparoscopy/hysteroscopy in 2006 (prior to the treatments) where an endometrial cyst was removed from one ovary, as well as one polyp from the uterus and some adhesions from the tubes. I have been getting continuously checked since then and my uterus, ovaries are clear from anything. My husband has had 3 TESE procedures, and good looking sperm was found each time and lots of it has been frozen.
We had 2 treatments in 2007, 1 in 2008, and 2 in 2009. In the first cycle (with fresh sperm) I had 14 eggs, 3 fertilized, and 2 grade A embryos were transferred. In my second and 3rd cycle I had 20 eggs (different protocols used in each of the treatments) and none fertilized. I hyperstimulated severely in cycle # 2 and ended up in the hospital. I was told we had an egg issue and to try with donor eggs. We took a year off to think about it and switched clinics. In 2009, cycle # 4, we had 15 eggs (frozen sperm), 3 fertilized and 2 grade A embryos were transferred on day 3. In cycle #5, we had 15 eggs again (frozen sperm), 7 fertilized, and we had 2 morulas transferred. We have a lot of trust in our doctor and clinic used for the past 2 treatments, and have a great relationship. The clinic is a stat of the art building with all new technology. This doctor does not think I have egg quality issues since I had good embryos (although very few of them) in the last two cycles, and thinks we should keep trying. However, we know it is not normal that within our age group we have not succeeded yet. It is hard to not think that there is something wrong with us. I stimulate very well in terms of numbers, and the protocol has been decreased (amount of drugs) with each treatment (always yielding a high number of eggs). We have tried acupuncture, yoga, bed rest, no bed rest, and all kinds of things. We do have a possibility to try one treatment in the US (due to the expenses), but are not sure of what we should do.
Any thoughts would be appreciated. What do you think of my egg quality issue? Would a US clinic suggest donor eggs? I would really like to try with mine...Best regards from Austria.
Hello S. from Austria,
Based on the history you have given me, it sounds like you may be a PCO-type ovarian stimulator. That is why you have so many eggs, and had hyperstimulation syndrome. The good part of that is that you yield lots of eggs. There have been some studies that show a decrease pregnancy rate in PCO patients, however, and it is thought that it is because they stimulate too much. This leads to unequal maturation of the eggs within. Certainly, you seem to have had good quality (albeit external quality) embryos in the latter two cycles. At your age, I would have expected a pregnancy, easily. One concern is whether the sperm is contributing to poor embryos (again internal quality/genetically), because of your husband's CF gene. The embryo could still look good but be genetically abnormal. The only way to know this is to do preimplantation genetic screening, preferably by polar body biopsy and CGH, to verify that only normal embryos are transferred. CGH, or "comparitive genomic hybridization" is a genetic test that analyzes the chromosomal integrity of an egg or embryo. In IVF, it is ideally done in women under the age of 39 who have more than 6 healthy embryos after fertilization. They can be her own or donor eggs.
I would not recommend that you give up yet. If you give up, you certainly will fail. Since your ovary stimulates so well, and you are young, I think your chances of pregnancy are still high. The alternative to the above genetic testing on the embryos, would be to go to donor sperm, rather that donor eggs, in order to eliminate that paternal genetic factor. I know that you husband would probably prefer a genetic child, however, so in that case, you just have to keep trying.
If you came to me or any other clinic in the U.S., I don't think we would be ready to give up with your eggs. I think we would continue to encourage you to keep trying with your own eggs. I recently had a patient, similar to you that seemed to have poor embryo quality in another clinic. They did three IVF cycles there and then were recommended to use donor eggs. Fortunately, her husband got transferred to my locale and they came to me for consultation. I encouraged them to try at least one more time with her own eggs, again since her ovaries stimulated well. They decided to go with my recommendation and in their first attempt, became pregnant.
Thank you Dr. Ramirez for your answer.
In the meantime, I just had a hysteroscopy 3 days ago and a polyp removed from the uterine wall, this polyp was not showing up on ultrasounds. Could you please elaborate on why you think I have PCO? I do ovulate every month, no diabetes issues, no acne, no absence of menstruation, none of the signs I have read are present in me, but since it is the first time I hear that, please explain me how I could have it and how does it affect stimulation? How is it better to deal with it?
I forgot to mention that in the last two treatments (with 2 embryos/morulas transferred each time) we did polar biopsy of the eggs and only the 2 perfect/healthy ones were transferred each time, still no success. My doctor recommends that we continue to do this polar biopsy and we will. What kind of stimulation would you recommend for me? What could have caused this polyp I just had removed? Could it be the same stimulation drugs (estrogen), which is given to me as part of the treatments that made my uterine tissue grown into a polyp? (it was a long, flat polyp, not the regular ones that can be seen by ultrasound).
With regards to the couple you mention in the last paragraph, what did you do different from their 3 previous treatments that could have led to success? Is it just a matter of numbers/attempts, that we need to keep trying? The more one fails, the harder it is to believe it could happen....and I know mental power can do lots for either direction.
We might try one more treatment here (much more affordable) and then have a final treatment in the States. We are definitely not ready to give up! Thanks again!
There are many variations of PCO. Not all fit the classic descriptions. In your case, what makes me think that you have a PCO tendency is the fact that you overstimulated and developed hyperstimulation syndrome. I have had many patients that have surprised me in the same way. They are thin, have regular menstrual cycles, don't have any other PCO-type tendencies, yet they stimulate like a PCO patient. That is, their ovaries are very sensitive to the fertility medications. Since you don't have any of the other PCO findings, the only thing to keep in mind is that your ovaries are very sensitive to stimulation, so that the next time, a low dose protocol will be used and you don't develop hyperstimulation syndrome.
In terms of stimulation protocols, with my PCO patients I use a "step-up" protocol. Patients start at a low dose of Follistim 150IU for three days then the estradiol level is checked for response. If there is not a high response then I step up the dosage to Follistim 150IU + Menopur 75. We continue the same pattern of checking and adjusting the dosage as needed. I don't use Lupron agonist suppression (long protocol), but instead use the Antagonist Ganerelix. When the follicles are appropriate sized, I trigger with Lupron 0.5 mg instead of Ovidrel. This combination and protocol has been shown to be effective in preventing hyperstimulation syndrome.
Polyps are normal. It is very common and is due to an overgrowth of endometrial tissue. The finding is probably not significant in terms of pregnancy chances, but we prefer to remove them anyway so that they can't potentially interfere.
In terms of my couple, I used a completely different protocol than what she used previously, and some additional medications. Different clinics have different success rates because of differences in their protocols and techniques. "Failing" is when you stop trying. As long as you continue to try, you have a chance of success and that is what you have to focus on. Focus on the goal, not the pathway.
Edward J. Ramirez, M.D., FACOG
Executive Medical Director
The Fertility and Gynecology Center
Monterey Bay IVF Program
Monterey, California, U.S.A.
***See continuing follow up to this question on May 16th, 2010...